First off this sounds great, I was always hoping for some other way of enjoying the Eve universe and was hoping for a console FPS every since CCP said they were looking into console development.
Will it work?
Being a console gamer primarily, despite spending a lot of time in New Eden and having two accounts, I know just how popular FPS multiplayer is. Long after the single-player campaign is over multiplayer keeps on kicking. But there is the first hurdle, console gamers are used to there FPSes having a singleplayer campaign. Granted some people dont always care about the story or the reason for why your on a planet blasting super soldiers in the face but with Eve it could be very different. If your just thrown into a universe where your fighting for control of somewhere for fun it’s all good, but will the control pad crowd want to take orders from someone on a keyboard in a different game?
Multiplayer on console revolves around deathmatch and team-deathmatch, quick fights where you jump in, have some fun then leave. We don’t really plan ahead to meet up and take someone on, granted you have clans who might meet up a few times a week but thats not the norm and with all thats being contested in New Eden will they really want to turn up and defend a zone instead of playing Madden or Fifa?
And how will these zones be contested? You cant expect someone to defend an area if there not online, the same goes for capturing a zone, one way would be to have set times of when people are taking a zone, such as deciding to invade and the defenders are sent a warning to their Live or PSN account that they are being attacked in 24 hours, almost like the wardec system, to give them some time to prepare.
But on consoles we look for kills, holding some ground for some space pilots in the sky doesn’t sound great, if the fights can be short and fun then great for planetside, but space farers could see there planets lost in a few hours.
Subscriptions
Currently FPSes on console are not subscription based, you buy the game and play, maybe buy some new maps, but the core is free. Many console gamers find the thought of paying monthly for a game a rip off, we live in a land of sequels, we will gladly pay for a new game because it promises something new, new maps, weapons and a fresh challenge even if it is pretty much the same game. Most now offer ranking and levelling systems within the multiplayer side to keep people playing and buying new maps, its an incentive to better your character, bragging rights, access to new weapons, but all with the main goal of keeping people playing. Now with Dust what incentives will there be? If alliances can fund you and supply you with what you need, whats to stop some Dust corps being heavily invested in from day one and having all they need and finding there enemies are nowhere near as powerful, this would create a system like Eve where the huge alliances battle each other and smaller alliances and corps have the little fights, no console gamer would be happy with being left out of the big fights because people aren’t buying them things they need, we dont like the thought of being limited because of other peoples lack of funds.
There would need to be a console only element for deathmatches and the like, where the players have to earn the skill to use certain weapons and vehicles that they can use in capturing planets for pilots, it would stop any chance of a power gap between corps due to being handed all the best weapons and would give us console gamers that all important incentive to keep playing.
Also we would need to be given the ability to take over planets ourselves, thereby letting us build our own little empires which Eve players would need to hire other Dust players to remove from there planets, if console gamers feel they are making a difference and not just the hired hands we might pay a subscription.
Final Thoughts
Dust is going to need a perfect launch, with a solid console only element to keep us entertained while CCP iron out and balance the crossover element as I imagine will be needed shortly after launch. We arent the kind of gamers who will continue to play something in the promise that it’ll be fixed soon unless there are other elements to enjoy, especially if we’re paying monthly. Hopefully they’ll go the boxed buy once route, then release some new maps, or planets for us to pay for and fight on when not helping out the pilots. Or they could see how The Agency and DC Universe fare on PS3 and whether console gamers even want an MMO.